Did you think it was over, now that SB 276 has been passed and Governor Newsom said that he would sign it, as long as a companion bill with a few added amendments also gets passed?
Of course, it’s not…
Elisa Song’s Letter to Governor Newsom
While many of us wanted Governor Newsom to sign SB 276 in its original form, as he had promised, without the added amendments that weaken the law, most see it it as an acceptable compromise.
And then there are the anti-vaccine folks who want Newsom to veto SB 276 so that kids can continue to get inappropriate medical exemptions and remain unprotected and at risk against vaccine preventable diseases.
“I am a pediatrician trying to do the best I can for the children in my practice. And the best is not simply repeating that vaccines are “safe and effective.” Because they’re not 100% safe. Because they’re not 100% effective. Because parents are asking questions. Because parents are afraid and want to do the best for their children. And because we, as primary care physicians, need to be able to practice the art and science of medicine to the best of our abilities, for the child sitting in front of us, without bureaucratic handcuffs and fear of retribution.”
Elisa Song’s Letter to Governor Newsom
No one says vaccines are 100% safe and effective, but they are very effective with few risks.
Parents are afraid because of the anti-vaccine rhetoric and misinformation they see and read on the Internet and sometimes from holistic type doctors who pander to their fears.
“SB 276 continues to place the decision regarding an individual child’s vaccine risk/benefit assessment and whether or not that child qualifies for a vaccine medical exemption in the hands of the government.”
Elisa Song’s Letter to Governor Newsom
This is not true.
SB 276 simply says that you can’t make up your own reasons for why kids can’t get vaccinated and protected.
“SB 276 continues to too narrowly limit the criteria for “appropriate” vaccine exemptions to those contraindications detailed by the CDC, AAP and ACIP. These criteria do not take into account the emerging field of vaccinomics pioneered by the Mayo Clinic and the latest research on increased risk for various chronic illnesses including autoimmunity after vaccination in certain vulnerable populations. Epigenetics is making it increasingly clear that the one-size-fits-all CDC schedule will not work. “
Elisa Song’s Letter to Governor Newsom
As other states have done, SB 276 and SB 714, set rules on what counts as a medical exemption.
“SB276 continues to essentially eliminate all medical exemptions, even those consistent with the CDC, ACIP or AAP guidelines. By arbitrarily limiting the number of medical exemptions a physician may write to 4 in any calendar year before triggering investigation, SB 276 will deter physicians from writing ANY exemptions for fear of irreparable damage to their professional reputation, financial security, and emotional trauma, even if ultimately found innocent. How will a physician decide which 4 children are “deserving” of medical exemptions each year, in order to prevent an automatic investigation once they write that 5th exemption?”
Elisa Song’s Letter to Governor Newsom
Since few children should actually need a true medical exemption, the limits in SB 276 are hardly arbitrary. And since what counts as a true medical exemptions is rarely arbitrary either, doctors who write five or more true medical exemptions in a year will have nothing to fear when those exemptions are reviewed.
“A Harvard study has found that 2.6% of people vaccinated will have a vaccine injury. California’s current medical exemption rate of 0.7% falls far below this number, implying that there are many children whose vaccine injuries could have been avoided if an appropriate medical exemption were written by their physician.”
Elisa Song’s Letter to Governor Newsom
The Harvard Pilgrim Health Care, Inc. report did not find “that 2.6% of people vaccinated will have a vaccine injury.”
It actually found possible reactions in 2.6% of vaccinations. And I hope that everyone is aware that a possible reaction is not the same as a vaccine injury…
Also, in addition to the fact that current rate of medical exemptions in California is far higher than 0.7%, it is the clusters of medical exemptions in many schools that are the problem.
“Until such time when vaccine risks and benefits can be clearly defined in broader terms that take into account personal and family history and epigenetics, this risk needs to be taken on by each parent and each child. And where there is risk, there must be choice. And where there is uncertainty, the BEST person to help that parent navigate vaccines is the person who knows that child’s medical and family history best – THEIR PHYSICIAN.”
Elisa Song’s Letter to Governor Newsom
Elisa Song talks a lot about the risks of vaccines, or at least what she thinks puts kids at risk, including family history and epigenetics.
“I believe in public health, yet I care for individual children and families who sit across from me everyday, trusting that I am giving them valid, scientific, evidence-based information that will keep their individual baby safe and healthy, and believing that I am providing them with true informed consent.”
Elisa Song’s Letter to Governor Newsom
It would be great if she truly were giving her patient’s “valid, scientific, evidence-based information” and “true informed consent.”
She’s not…
“I learned how to integrate conventional pediatrics with functional medicine, holistic nutrition, homeopathy, acupuncture, herbal medicine and essential oils – and it changed my life!”
Elisa Song
Notice anything missing?
She never talks about the risks of getting a vaccine-preventable disease.
And she overstates the risks of vaccines.
“While the media and common public opinion are quick to say that the link between vaccines and autism has been absolutely disproved, they have not done their due diligence research.”
Measles: Know the Facts by Dr. Elisa Song, M.D.
It is hard to make a truly informed decision when your doc downplays the risks of natural disease, makes you afraid to get vaccinated, and tries to sell you natural therapies that we know won’t prevent infections and won’t actually boost your immune system.
More on Anti-Vaccine Pediatricians
- Is SB 276 a Civil Rights Issue?
- More Questions to Help You Become a Vaccine Skeptic
- Would a Doctor Ever Say These Things About Vaccines?
- How the Anti-Vaccine Movement Hurts Autistic Families
- What Makes Someone Anti-Vaccine?
- Why Is Lying About Vaccines Not Criminal?
- What Are the Greatest Tricks Anti-Vaccine Folks Use to Persuade Parents to Skip Vaccines?
- Is There Evidence for That Therapy, or No?
- A Parent’s Guide to Complementary and Integrative Medicine
- How is it that antivaccine pediatricians keep their medical licenses?
- Clear Answers and Smart Advice About Your Baby’s Shots
- American Academy of Pediatrics Emphasizes Safety and Importance of Vaccines
- Why Vaccine Opponents Think They Know More Than Medical Experts
- Boost Your Immune System?
- More Boosting the Immune System
- Boosting the immune system – that’s what vaccines do
- Boosting the immune system – sorting science from myth
It would be great if she truly were giving her patient’s “valid, scientific, evidence-based information” and “true informed consent.”
She’s not…
Prove it.
Health and Human Service has violated US Code 42 USC 300AA-27C since 1998.
Lawsuit was filed on 7/9/18 in the United States District Court Southern District Of New York
Case 1:18-cv-03215-JMF Document 18 Filed 07/09/18
Pages 1-3 of the court document can be found at the ICAN blog under ICAN VS HHS
JULY 9, 2018 STIPULATED ORDER CONFIRMING NON-COMPLIANCE WITH 42 USC 300AA-27C.
The court ordered HHS to provide the listed documents in the lawsuit. HHS complied: This stipulated order shows that HHS has not acted in its duties regarding vaccine safety, forcing 78 million American children into a vaccine program with no safety provisions. HHS has neglected to perform any safety testing of any vaccines for 33 years as mandated by the 1986 NCVIP
From the legal document:
Whereas, on August 25, 2017 Informed Consent Action Network (ICAN) submitted a Freedom Of Information Act request (the FOUA Request) to the Department of Health And Human Services (HHS or the Department), which was assigned control number 2017-0119-FOIA-OS, that sought the following records:
Any and all reports transmitted to the Committee on Energy and commerce of the House of Representatives and the Committee on Labor and Human Resources of the Senate by the Secretary o HHS pursuant to 42 U.S. C. 300aa-27 ( c ).
WHEREAS, on April 12, 2018, ICAN filed a Complaint for Declaratory and Injunctive Relief in the United States District Court, Southern District of New York against HHS seeking records, if any, responsive to the FOIA Request:
WHEREAS, (IOS) maintains the official correspondence file of the Secretary of HHS, including reports to Congress by the Secretary of HHS, and therefore those files were most likely to contain records responsive to the FOUA Request;
WHEREAS, on June 27, 2018, HHS sent ICAN the following response to the FOIA Request;
The (Department)’s searches for the records did not locate and records responsive to your request. The Department of Health and Human Services (HHS) Immediate Office of the Secretary (IOS) conducted a through search of its document tracking systems. The Department also conducted a comprehensive review of all relevant indexes of HHS Secretarial Correspondence records maintained at Federal Records Center that remain in the custody of HHS. These searches did not locate record responsive to your request, or indications that records responsive to your request and in the custody of HHS are located at Federal Records Centers.
The remainder of the documents is legal-eze, signatures and the signature of the Hon. Jesse M. Furman, U.S.D.J.
The lawsuit forced HHS to either provide copies of its biennial vaccine safety reports to Congress or admit it never filed these reports. The result of the lawsuit is that HHS had to admit that it never, not even once, submitted a single biennial report to Congress detailing the improvements in vaccine safety.
She’s definitely giving “real” informed consent to parents, which is ALOT more than I can say about the average fear mongering pediatricians today. I’ve been dismissed from practices for simply questioning real side effects that I read on the CDC website!! Absolutely ridiculous!!!
Why hasn’t this woman lost her license yet? Anyone recommending homeopathic ‘medicine’, which she routinely does, has clearly forgotten how to science and should be treated accordingly.
“Hysterical” is a sexist term. She’s not pretending not to be a “hysterical antivaxxer” – she’s pretending not to be an evil or stubbornly misinformed antivaxxer (depending on whether she thinks antivaxxers are paid to lie (like Wakefield) or have thinking problems.
Sadly, of course, she’s lying – she’s not hysterical, but she is evil or stubbornly misinformed. Since she sells tap water as medicine, I’m going with evil