Rand Paul – VAXOPEDIA

Wait, we had vaccines when Ben Franklin was around?

You can learn what Benjamin Franklin thought about vaccines from his autobiography.

What Did Benjamin Franklin Say About Vaccines?

“Those who would give up essential Liberty, to purchase a little temporary Safety, deserve neither Liberty nor Safety.”
Benjamin Franklin

The Benjamin Franklin quote many anti-vaccine folks are using these days (do anti-vaccine folks get daily talking points to use?) doesn’t really have anything to do with vaccines though, at least not in the way that they think it does.

“The Franklin quote he nodded to on Tuesday, ironically, means the opposite of what Paul was arguing. When Franklin said, “Those who would give up essential Liberty, to purchase a little temporary Safety, deserve neither Liberty nor Safety,” he was opposing the Penn family’s attempt to carve out an exception for themselves from the Pennsylvania General Assembly’s attempt to tax their lands for the collective good of frontier defense. The liberty Franklin was defending was the liberty the rest of us deserve now, too — liberty to choose to protect ourselves.”
Saad B Omer on Rand Paul is wrong: Vaccines are no threat to liberty

It should be clear that Ben Franklin’s quote shouldn’t be used to attack vaccine mandates. If anything, it can be used to attack free-riders and those who skip or delay vaccines and try to hide in the herd!

“It is a quotation that defends the authority of a legislature to govern in the interests of collective security. It means, in context, not quite the opposite of what it’s almost always quoted as saying but much closer to the opposite than to the thing that people think it means.”
Benjamin Wittes onBen Franklin’s Famous ‘Liberty, Safety’ Quote Lost Its Context In 21st Century

Interestingly, Benjamin Franklin did famously talk about vaccines, or at least smallpox variolation.

“In 1736 I lost one of my sons, a fine boy of four years old, by the small-pox, taken in the common way. I long regretted bitterly, and still regret that I had not given it to him by inoculation. This I mention for the sake of parents who omit that operation, on the supposition that they should never forgive themselves if a child died under it; my example showing that the regret may be the same either way, and that, therefore, the safer should be chosen.”
Benjamin Franklin

He got a little temporary safety, avoiding the side effects of variolation, but what were the consequences? What did he lose?

What do you lose when you make decisions about vaccines based on vaccine misinformation?

What do folks like Rand Paul have to gain by speaking out against vaccines?

More on Benjamin Franklin and Vaccines

Wait, what?

Anti-vaccine folks actually applauded Rand Paul’s testimony at the Senate Health Committee Hearing on Vaccines and Outbreaks?

Why Did Anti-Vaccine Folks Applaud Rand Paul’s Testimony at the Senate Health Committee Hearing on Vaccines and Outbreaks?

Surprisingly, many of the things he said weren’t anti-vaccine.

I guess they ignored those parts…

…given the choice, I do believe that the benefits of most vaccines vastly outweigh the risks.
I’m not hear to say don’t vaccinate your kids… if this hearing is for persuasion, I’m all for the persuasion. I vaccinated myself. I vaccinated my kids.
For myself and my kids, I believe that the benefits of vaccines greatly outweigh the risks…

So why were they cheering?

Because that’s not all he said…

“Today, instead of persuasion, many governments have taken to mandating a whole host of vaccines, including vaccines for non-lethal diseases.”
Sen Rand Paul

While some vaccine-preventable diseases are more deadly than others, they can all be deadly. From rotavirus and HPV to hepatitis A, these diseases can kill people.

Which vaccine-preventable disease does he think is non-lethal?

“Sometimes these vaccine mandates have run amok. As when the government mandated a rotavirus vaccine that was later recalled because it was causing intestinal blockage in children.”
Sen Rand Paul

That’s an interesting example of “the government” that has run amok…

Which “government” mandated that the original rotavirus vaccine be given to children?

As Senator Paul hopefully understands, the Federal government doesn’t mandate vaccines for anyone. And since it must be given at such a young age, even states don’t actually mandate that the rotavirus vaccine be given to children…

Even today, there are no mandates for the rotavirus vaccine.

If there were, it still wouldn’t mean giving up your Liberty, after all, vaccine mandates don’t mean forced vaccination.

“It is wrong to say that there are no risks to vaccines. Even the government admits that children are sometimes injured by vaccines. Since 1988, over $4 billion has been paid out from the Vaccine Injury Compensation Program. Despite the government admitting to and paying $4 billion for vaccine injuries, no informed consent is used or required when you vaccinate your child. This may be the only medical procedure in today’s medical world where an informed consent is not required. “
Sen Rand Paul

No one says that there are no risks to vaccines. That’s a classic anti-vaccine talking point.

What folks actually say is that vaccines are safe, with few serious risks.

And the $4 billion that Rand Paul and anti-vaccine folks often talk about has been paid out over more than 30 years, during a time that we have given nearly 300 million doses of vaccines each and every year!

But what’s that he said about informed consent?

Why wouldn’t informed consent be given or be required before getting a vaccine?

Of course, parents get informed consent before getting vaccines.

They don’t get informed consent if they decide to skip or delay their child’s vaccines after getting bad information.

“Now proponents of mandatory government vaccination argue that parents who refuse to vaccinate their children risk spreading these diseases to the immunocompromised community. There doesn’t seem to be enough evidence of this happening for it to be recorded as a statistic, but it could happen. But if the fear of this is valid, are we to find that next we will be mandating flu vaccine?”
Sen Rand Paul

Lastly, why didn’t Sen Paul find evidence that intentionally unvaccinated kids are spreading disease to the immunocompromised community?

Maybe he didn’t look…

It happens.

Do we need it to happen more often so that it becomes a large statistic before he and others will advocate that folks get vaccinated to attend school?

Do you understand have a better understand now why anti-vaccine folks were cheering after his testimony?

“If you believe in Liberty, that’s fine, don’t get immunized. But I don’t think that you need to necessarily expose others to disease.”
Sen Bill Cassidy

It should give you a better understanding both of Rand Paul’s ideas and those of the anti-vaccine movement.

More on Rand Paul’s Testimony at the Senate Health Committee Hearing on Vaccines and Outbreaks

VAXOPEDIA – News on the Latest Measles Outbreaks of 2019
VAXOPEDIA – What Will House and Senate Lawmakers Do as They Investigate Measles Outbreaks?
VAXOPEDIA – Do I Have to Sign a Consent Form Before Getting a Vaccine?
VAXOPEDIA – How Do You Provide Informed Consent to Vaccination?
VAXOPEDIA – How Can I Get Vaccinated If My Parents Are Anti-Vaccine?
VAXOPEDIA – Do Vaccine Mandates Force Parents to Vaccinate Their Kids?
VAXOPEDIA – Ask 8 Questions Before You Skip a Vaccine
VAXOPEDIA – What Are the Greatest Tricks Anti-Vaccine Folks Use to Persuade Parents to Skip Vaccines?
VAXOPEDIA – What Is Vaccine Choice?
VAXOPEDIA – Kat Von D Just Took Away Your Vaccine Choice
VAXOPEDIA – Who Is at Risk If You Don’t Vaccinate Your Kids?
VAXOPEDIA – People with Cancer Are at Risk from Unvaccinated Kids
VAXOPEDIA – Is My Fully Vaccinated Child at Risk from Your Unvaccinated Kids?
VAXOPEDIA – More About Measles Deaths in the United States
VAXOPEDIA – Why Are You Still Worried About the MMR Vaccine?
VAXOPEDIA – More Measles Myths
VAXOPEDIA – Everything You Need to Know About the Measles Vaccine
VAXOPEDIA – Anti-Vaccine Points Refuted A Thousand Times
VAXOPEDIA – 10 Reasons You Aren’t Vaccinating Your Kids
VAXOPEDIA – How To Counter Vaccine Hesitancy
VAXOPEDIA – How Pediatricians Should Talk to Vaccine Hesitant Parents
VAXOPEDIA – Where Are All of the Vaccine Advocates?
VAXOPEDIA – Are New Federal Vaccine Laws Coming?
VAXOPEDIA – 50 Ways to Get Educated About Vaccines
HELP Hearing Vaccines Save Lives: What Is Driving Preventable Disease Outbreaks?
Hearing on “Confronting a Growing Public Health Threat: Measles Outbreaks in the U.S.”
Rand Paul: Sure, Vaccines Are OK, But We Shouldn’t Trade ‘Liberty’ for ‘False Sense of Security’
Senator Bill Cassidy Challenges Senator Rand Paul on Flu Vaccine Immunization
Sen. Rand Paul says government should not force people to receive vaccinations
Rand Paul’s weak case against mandatory vaccines undercuts efforts to counter measles outbreak
EDITORIAL: Measles, anti-vaccine myths and some advice for Illinois
Vaccine informed consent – mandates and liability
School vaccine mandates are against the Nuremberg Code?
MMWR – Notes from the Field: Varicella-Associated Death of a Vaccinated Child with Leukemia — California, 2012
Children with cancer: stories from the 2011 measles outbreaks
‘I Give A Damn!’ – Leukemic Marin 1st Grader Pleads For Ban On Unvaccinated Children In Schools
Mixing unvaccinated children with vaccinated children: Whose rights prevail?